An Investigation Tainted by Bad Science and False Evidence Led to 2004 Wrongful Arson Conviction of Cape Cod Architect, Robert Therrien

New England Innocence Project Files Motion for New Trial
Seeking to Overturn Mr. Therrien’s Wrongful Conviction and Help Clear His Name

Barnstable, MA, November 12, 2026 — The New England Innocence Project, in partnership with attorneys at McDermott Will & Schulte and retired DLA Piper partner Rob Sherman, announces today that it has filed a Motion for New Trial for architect Robert Therrien of Townsend, MA [formerly of Harwich]. The motion details how outdated fire science and false evidence led to Mr. Therrien’s wrongful arson conviction in 2004 and how “justice was not done” in his case. 

Mr. Therrien was wrongfully convicted of setting fire to the office space he rented inside the historic Theatre Marketplace in Dennis, MA. He was 53 years old at the time of his arrest. He had spent years building his business, Gaffney Architects, which took on municipal projects such as the Randolph Town Hall, Halifax Police Department, and Bridgewater Public Library. Mr. Therrien was stunned to find himself accused of burning down the business he had long nurtured and loved. He believed the truth would come out and the system would deliver justice, until the moment he was convicted of something he didn’t do.

Background on the Case
No witnesses were present when the fire broke out at the Theatre Marketplace in the early morning hours of July 19, 2001. In the hours and days after the fire, Mr. Therrien quickly became the prime suspect. He had worked late in his rented office, the locked area of the building where the fire broke out, and was one of the few people with access. At trial, the Commonwealth presented outdated fire “science” to claim that the fire was started with “an open flame to an ignitable liquid” in the attic above Mr. Therrien’s drafting room. Fire investigators focused narrowly on this area because of the now-debunked belief that the location with the most damage must be where the fire originated. To shore up their theory of an intentionally set fire, the Commonwealth presented unreliable evidence of an accelerant known as “fuel oil residue” at the scene. However, new scientific analysis shows that no chemical evidence of fuel oil, or any accelerant, was actually present. Notably, the same lab worker who testified about the presence of an accelerant in Robert’s case also testified in the case of another wrongful arson conviction, NEIP client Nicole Chuminski, as well as in multiple known wrongful arson convictions in MA.

With the benefit of modern fire science, this fire could not be classified as arson today. Instead, potential electrical sources—including a damaged electrical outlet—which were never properly examined or investigated, were more likely to have started the fire. Biased by the initial faulty conclusion that the fire was arson, police and prosecutors tried to bolster their case against Mr. Therrien with a misleading picture of his finances, arguing that he burned down his office space to obtain insurance benefits. To support their case, they presented an accounting expert whose analysis did not follow proper accounting procedures. He not only misrepresented the value of the anticipated insurance proceeds but also relied on inconsistent time periods when comparing debt and income over time. His testimony painted a false picture of Mr. Therrien’s financial status. Contrary to this false narrative, he was financially secure, had successfully run his own business for over 15 years, was in negotiations to sell the business and remain a salaried employee, and owned two homes.

“Robert’s case is yet another example of the cascade of errors we see in so many wrongful arson convictions: a misguided fire investigation based on outdated methods, false testimony suggesting the presence of an accelerant at the scene without scientific support, and a manufactured motive that cherry-picked and manipulated financial details while ignoring others,” said Stephanie Hartung, New England Innocence Project Senior Staff Attorney. “But the jury that convicted Robert wasn’t aware of any of these problems with the investigation. With the new evidence presented in his Motion for New Trial, Robert hopes that the truth will finally come out.”

“When a conviction is built on bad science like it was in Robert’s case, the integrity of our entire legal system is compromised,” said Laura Carey, New England Innocence Project Staff Attorney. “The physical evidence here is unequivocal: no scientific proof of an accelerant was ever found at the scene. This case presents a vital opportunity to confront systemic misconduct, uphold scientific integrity, and ensure that the false presentation of scientific evidence never replaces the truth.”

A Pattern of Bad Science in Arson Exonerations
Mr. Therrien’s case was investigated and prosecuted before a revolution in fire science that has led to the exoneration of 95 people—including nine in Massachusetts—who were wrongfully convicted of arson. As in Mr. Therrien’s case, many of these wrongful convictions relied on outdated, unscientific fire investigation methods that overlooked or ignored evidence of an accidental fire. At Robert’s trial, fire investigators used the same unscientific methodologies and theories about the fire’s cause and origin that were present in dozens of known arson exoneration cases.

The Devastating Impact of a Wrongful Conviction
Wrongful convictions devastate individuals, families, and communities. On the night of the fire, Robert lost his entire business, Gaffney Architects, which he had spent years building. His wrongful conviction damaged his reputation and status in the community and tore apart his family. Mr. Therrien was sentenced to serve two years in prison for something he didn’t do, and continues to be haunted by a harmful narrative that impacts his ability to heal, find work, and rebuild his life. While nothing can give Robert back all he has lost, bringing the truth to light can restore some sense of peace for him and his family.

“Being wrongfully convicted was like a death sentence to me. I had no hope, and everything was lost - my integrity, my business, everything I had achieved, my family,” said Mr. Therrien about his wrongful conviction. “It felt like being hit by a train.”

“This is a case that was not in the headlines or on the national stage, but was one of critical importance to one man whose life was ruined in the wake of an ill-conceived and flawed prosecution,” said Rob Sherman, former Partner with DLA Piper and NEIP pro bono counsel for Robert Therrien.  “As a litigator for over 40 years, it has been an honor to work alongside the New England Innocence Project team to right this wrong and finally get justice for Robert.”

“As a team of attorneys used to working at the intersection of science and law, it was especially rewarding to apply our skills to interrogate the science used in this conviction and shed light on unreliable methods and misinterpreted results,” said Sarah Fischer, Partner at McDermott Will & Schulte and NEIP pro bono counsel. “We hope this will help achieve some measure of justice for Robert.” 

Next Steps
The Attorney General’s Office, which initially prosecuted Mr. Therrien’s case, recently launched a new Justice Review Unit, and our legal team has presented them with new evidence of Robert’s innocence. They now have the option to agree to the motion for new trial or fight it. If the Attorney General’s Office opposes the motion, Robert will ask the Court to hold an evidentiary hearing to examine all of the new evidence of innocence and grant him a new trial.

MEDIA CONTACTS: 
Jordan Salvatoriello, jordan@newenglandinnocence.org, 617-733-6725

ABOUT THE NEW ENGLAND INNOCENCE PROJECT
The New England Innocence Project is an independent social justice non-profit that frees innocent people from prison, supports individuals and families impacted by long-term incarceration, and fights to end the systemic harms of the criminal legal system in New England. By providing free forensic testing, investigation, experts, and an experienced legal team, we can exonerate the innocent and bring them home to their loved ones. Through the Exoneree Network, we provide comprehensive support — from housing and seasonal stipends to mental health care and job training — so our community can heal and rebuild in freedom. We also use our expertise about wrongful convictions to educate and advocate for reforms to prevent future tragedies. Visit NewEnglandInnocence.org for more information.

Next
Next

Innocence group asks court to unseal records about Brockton police lieutenant’s “materially false” statements